|
« Out Of Many; Many More |
Main
| Making The Most Of The Oregon Coast: Port Orford Heads & Pistol River Parks »
We're Not Violent, And We'll Kill You To Prove It
September 18, 2006
Is there something just a little bit off, here? From today's wires, via The Houston Post: CAIRO, Egypt — An al-Qaida-linked extremist group warned Pope Benedict XVI on Monday that he and the West were "doomed," as protesters returned to the streets across the Muslim world to demand more of an apology from the pontiff for his remarks about Islam and violence. The Mujahedeen Shura Council, an umbrella organization of Sunni Arab extremist groups that includes al-Qaida in Iraq, issued a statement on a Web forum vowing to continue its holy war against the West. The authenticity of the statement could not be independently verified. Stephen Brown, in FrontPage mag today: Pope Benedict released a storm of outrage in the Muslim world last week during his six-day trip to his native Bavaria when he quoted a medieval Byzantine emperor during a lecture at Regensburg University. The supposedly offensive passage the Pope cited occurred in an exchange the medieval Christian Emperor Paleologus II had with a Persian scholar, in which he called the Mohammed’s teachings regarding Holy War “evil and inhumane.” Benedict XVI went even further in his lecture, saying that to spread a faith through violence is against reason and therefore against God, since God is a rational being. Does it not seem as though Muslim extremists are proving his point, even as he has apologized amidst the outrage? Where are the many good, majority Muslims who eschew violence, threats, forced conversions, and Holy War; who welcome constructive dialog and rapprochement with The West? Why do they not speak out against the rage, the burnings in effigy in response to Benedict's concerns, such as that pictured above right - in Basra, Iraq? Are they afraid? TECHNORATI TAGS: POPE BENEDICT, VIOLENCE, ISLAM, MUJHAHEDEEN SHURA COUNCIL, FORCED CONVERSIONS, HEAD TAX, HOLY WAR> Posted by Matt Rosenberg at September 18, 2006 08:36 AM Comments:
It is generally recognized throughout the West that Islamic extremism will only come to an end when violent jihad has been delegitimized within the Islamic community. That is, the solution lies, and can only lie, within Islam itself. If that is so, how do we strengthen the cause of Muslim moderates by suggesting, as the Pope just inadvertently did, that holy war may be central to Islamic faith? Even if it were true, is it politic to emphasize the point, and thus support the very version of Islam the militants claim is the authentic one? Whose game are we playing here? You ask where the moderate Muslims are and wonder whether it is fear that keeps them silent. For some, it may be, and for good reason. But for many it may be fear of a differen sort, fear that embracing Western values of religious tolerance, free speech, democracy, and women's rights may jeopardize their faith. Is it really so surprising that they would be reluctant to do this? Should they be expected to respond positively to some non-Muslim scold giving them lectures on the meaning of their faith? I am not sure there is much we can do from outside the Muslim community to influence the course of the debate within it. Maybe we should just defend ourselves as best we can, and shut the f... up. Posted by: Tom Rekdal at September 18, 2006 11:11 AMPost a comment
|
|
| Site design by Mystic Sludge Design© | |