From Seattle writer and consultant Matt Rosenberg...

« Apple iPod Addicts Are Refugees From The Now | Main | Madagascar Cracks Down On Free Press »

Oozing Corpses On Display In San Francisco

May 27, 2005

In San Francisco, arts patrons are forking over $10 to $17 a head to see "The Universe Within," an exhibit of plasticized corpses and body parts in action poses. But an investigation is underway into exactly where the bodies came from; whether the subjects - all Asian - really wanted their dead bodies on public display; and whether the ooze presently coming from some of the displayed corpses poses health hazards. Details from the San Francisco Chronicle.

The immediate issue is that some of the corpses -- which have been injected with plastic and dissected to reveal muscles, bone and nerves -- are leaking. Fluid is beading on the surface of some tissues, a possible sign that the bodies were not properly processed.

The city's Department of Public Health has taken samples of the leaking fluid, and "so far, the tests are not showing any pathogenic organisms," said Dr. Rajiv Bhatia, director of occupational and environmental health. But the health department is still awaiting results showing exactly what the fluid is. "If the bodies aren't appropriately preserved, we would be concerned that they are decomposing," Bhatia said. "We need to see what our tests show before speculating."

...The corpses are part of an exhibition called "The Universe Within" at the Masonic Center on Nob Hill, designed to be both provocative and educational. In the words of a brochure, it is meant to leave visitors "with a deeper understanding of the body's form and function and a stronger appreciation for staying fit and healthy."

The "healthiness" message is already somewhat undercut by the questions stemming from the ooze, however. On a purely aesthetic scale, of course, this is fairly disgusting. I suppose now someone will have to buy a Cioppino and Chablis lunch for a newspaper or "alternative weekly" art critic, who will then feel compelled to weigh in with a declaration that the ooze "represents a primordial essence which, like art itself, is supposed to make us think, and feel." The "paradigm of revulsion," we will learn, "bravely confronts the artifice inherent in the present-day social contract."

Only a matter of days, I'm sure. In fact, a San Francisco P.R. firm already represents the Austrian TV producer behind the exhibit. The company declined comment to the Chron - but must be brainstorming along these lines right now.

Myself, I'm uncomfortably reminded of a Glasgow art exhibit which also prompted public health concerns: the centerpiece was blood sausages made from human blood.

Posted by Matt Rosenberg at May 27, 2005 12:06 PM

Comments:

You know, every time I see another one of these stories I become more and more convinced that art is the business of selling the emperor new clothes.

Posted by: Nathan Azinger at May 27, 2005 03:56 PM

.... "represents the fluid essence of humanity and its effort to escape the binding confines of our newly restrictive cultural norms ..."

...."we should embrace the forms, absorb the fluids, and bath in freedom we once knew ..."

Posted by: Iguana at May 27, 2005 07:31 PM

You know, as an artist, every time one of these situations comes up I cringe.
And in this case I can honestly say...oh get real. This is not art....this is EMBALMING BADLY DONE.
Sadly, today, most people think that if it's in bad taste or hideous....it MUST BE ART.
Wrong...art takes work, and alot of time and creativity.....and some people will like it, and some will hate it but in either case you have succeeded as an artist...it's only when they are indifferent that you have failed.
But if their skin is crawling....as in this case....it's just creepy.

Posted by: christmasghost at May 31, 2005 08:54 AM

I recently visited The Universe Within with one of my art classes. My reaction was one of ambiguance, on the one hand I was genuinely creeped out (though not at all disgusted or morally offended). At the same time I noticed that there were a number of people walking through the exhibit in absolute awe. To be honest, I wish I could have been one of them, but I had a hard time getting over the fact that the subjects were real human bodies in action poses, but there was nothing lifelike about them. Yes, I am aware that they are corpses. What I mean is that I have seen paintings and sculptures of people that one would swear looked alive, yet the real thing looked about as life-like as those Disney animatronic characters.

I think it is wrong to write something like this off as in bad taste (though I am not aware of how these subjects were obtained, I am assuming that these people consented to having this done post mortem). I walked away with the impression that, even though this is not my kind of thing, it was educational nontheless. If someone else can look at The Universe Within and be inspired to become an artist, doctor, whatever, then I think the purpose is served.

Posted by: Rob Blauser at June 7, 2005 07:29 PM

Let's get real. This is a cheap copy of an extremely well done exhibit by Gunther von Hagen. He developed plastination, an amazing technique which allows now just the preservation of these exhibits, but anatomical exhibits all over. Obviously, if they are leaking, the plastination was not well done. As long as no one (and I mean the individuals who presumably consented (???) to be dissected this way) is getting hurt, what's the harm. We are flesh and blood, so, if it bothers you, well, don't go. Deal with your Rylian ghosts in the privacy of your own thoughts or maybe just read a little Daniel Dennett before you start making judgments.

The above is said with a major caveat, however.

Posted by: george at June 20, 2005 08:23 PM

I am a bit confused as to why everyone posting here (and other blog sites) insist on critiquing this exhibit as art? It was not meant as art; it is an educational exhibit. If you are squeamish by nature, don't go. If anatomy class creeped you out, don't go. But if your mind is curious, if your intellect is alive and well, you just might like to see what a wonderful thing is the human body. On the outside, sometimes, a work of art (yes, art), and on the inside? Well it's a wonder to behold and contemplate. So many of us look for entertainment and cheap thrills, and have wholly forgotten the art of contemplation and awe. For everyone else, grow up. Science is fascinating, and even I don't adore potato bugs, but to be disgusted with anything in nature is just, well...small minded.

Posted by: Carla at June 23, 2005 03:05 PM

Post a comment









Remember personal info?