From Seattle writer and consultant Matt Rosenberg...

« No Excuses For Sung Koo Kim, The Oregon Panty Bandit | Main | Tipping Point: Arcata Council Opposes Iraq War »

Terror, Corruption and Impunity Reign In The Philippines

May 10, 2005

Another week gone by in the Philippines, and the scorecard shows one mayor, one bodyguard and one more radio commentator assassinated. Pervasive institutional corruption in this nation of island archipelagos is tied to organized crime and local government officials. It provides fertile grounds for Islamic terrorist groups such as Abu Sayyaf, and Jeemah Islamiyah, the latter of which envisions a transnational Southeast Asian Islamic state. Unless flailing President Gloria Arroyo can find a way to unify terrified citizens against the cancer of local corruption, the Philippines will continue to serve as a spawning ground for global terorrism.

To be allied with even putative reformists such as Arroyo, or to speak out against corruption is to put your life at risk.

The mayor of a town just outside Manila, Santa Rosa City, Leon Arcillas, was gunned down yesterday along with a bodyguard, moments after officiating a mass wedding. Law enforcement sources say the hit was similar to those perpetrated before by the New People's Army (NPA), an armed militia of the Communist Party of the Philippines. The NPA wounded Arcillas in an assassination attempt nearly two years ago, and has issued death threats to him since then. Arcillas was an ally of Arroyo, and Philippines National Police had recently begun a stepped-up campaign against loose firearms and hired killers.

BBC notes the Maoist NPA is branded a terrorist group by the U.S.; has assassinated public officialas before; has as many as 8,000 members, and has been fighting a guerilla battle for three decades.

Meanwhile, the Philippines retains its title as assassination central for journalists. A recent report by the Committee To Protect Journalists puts the nation at the top of the list, with 18 killings of journalists since 2000.

However, The Guardian reports that according to the National Union of Journalists of The Philippines (NUJP), the toll is actually 23 since 2000, the most recent being last Wednesday's killing of Klein Cantoneros, an outspoken radio critic of local government corruption.

A spokesperson for the Philippines Center For Investigative Journalism tells The Guardian that radio is a huge medium in the country, and a number of the journalists assassinated are fiery, anti-corruption commentators like Cantoneros, known as "blocktimers," who purchase time blocks to say whatever they want. Blocktimers may sometimes go overboard in their commentary, but hardly deserve to be killed. That they draw large audiences suggests many Phillipinos share their concerns, but live in silent fear, nonetheless.

Institutional corruption in The Phillipines is able to flourish partly because of the nation's dispersed, island geography; and runs straight to organized crime, law enforcement and the halls of local government. The Guardian:

Inday Espina-Varona, the chairwoman of the NUJP...(said)... "It's all to do with the consolidation of criminal and political power," she said, adding that in some areas, politicians and law enforcement officials appear to act with impunity. So when people find the way to local justice is blocked they naturally run to the media to air their grievances and in the local areas radio is king."

Any allegations of police complicity are unfounded, according to Supt. (Pedro, head of Task Force Newsmen, a special team investigating deaths of Philippine journalists) Tango. "The accusations are widespread but they are not accurate," he said. However he added: "We're not denying that some military and police personnel have been involved in some cases."

He also admitted that the national police chief took control of the Cantoneros investigation away from the Dipolog commander at the weekend after claims by the victims' relatives that local officers may have been linked to the crime. "The investigation is now being conducted by a regional level task force," Supt. Tango said.

Police corruption is not confined to individual officers. In March, all 529 officers of the North Abra provincial force were transferred amidst reports of corruption and links to organised crime....Espina-Varona said.."..there's a worrying pattern prevailing. It's not just journalists getting killed. It's many civic community leaders, environmental campaigners, human rights activists and anti-corruption activists. There won't be fundamental change until the culture of impunity ends."

In this lawless society, the two biggest Islamic terrorist threats - Abu Sayyaf and Jeemah Islamiyah - remain highly viable.

Presently,the Australian Foreign Ministry is warning of a high risk of a terrorist bombing in the Philippines targeting tourists or ex-pats.

A travel advisory from the Aussies stated:

Recent reports suggest that terrorists are in the final stages of planning an attack. Attacks could occur at any time, anywhere in the Phillipines.

The advisory identifies as possible targets coastal resorts, embassies, ex-pat housing complexes, malls, clubs, hotels, restaurants, bars, schools, places of worship, outdoor rec areas, tourist areas, and especially ferries.

The culture of cowardice and corruption which underpins the Phillipines' perpertual state of emergency will not be soon rectified, if Manilenya is right.

Posted by Matt Rosenberg at May 10, 2005 11:46 AM

Comments:

"Blocktimers" are a little like bloggers on the radio -- AM and not FM radio, mind you, which is mostly "talk". While the majority of Filipinos get their news from TV, AM radio stations give them the constantly updated news (ala CNN) and commentary (like blogging)throughout the day. Manila's elite and growing number of illustrado (well-educated middle-class) tend to get their information from newspapers.

One might question why the "blocktimers" are such a danger when the people who control things aren't listening. The answer is that if you want to motivate Filipinos from the grassroots level, you speak in Tagalog and you speak on the radio. However, if you want to get buy-in from the feudal clans that actually run everything, you speak in English and you speak on "Business Nightly" or write an Op-Ed piece.

Assasinations are more common in rural areas, since this is where mayors and their political dynasties -- far from the central government -- hold full sway over their constituents.

In defense of my country, however, let me point out that we aren't lawless (we actually have a lot of great laws that have been praised by the international community), it's just the implementation that sucks. Implementation is horrid due to corruption, but this is a limited explanation. All governments are corrupt, what separates the 1st world from the 3rd is only a matter of self-discipline and a long-term outlook.

You must remember that 32-37% of our national budget goes to servicing the interests of debts that were incurred during the time of Ferdinand Marcos. It was also during his term that he first promoted the concept of migrant labor.

This is the story of my country:

Because we cannot invest our money in the education of our populace and the infrastrucutre projects we require, we cannot contribute to the global market except in terms of providing raw materials.

Because we compete on an advantage that is easily duplicated by other nations, we must keep costs and wages low.

Because we pay our people a pittance, the only choice for them is to migrate.

Today the Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism estimates that we ship out 2,700 people a day. 65% of them women: domestic helpers, nannies, nurses. We fracture families to survive because our country does not have the budget to pay it's people a decent wage. We ship our best and our brightest. In Silicon Valley, 1 in 7 scientists is a Filipino.

We export our wealth and guarantee poverty, which only fuels the vicious cycle that ultimately ends in blood and tears.

Posted by: casualsavant at May 10, 2005 12:39 PM

Is an American Ex-Pat allowed to own firearms in the Philippines? Allowed to Carry on person?

Posted by: Bill at May 14, 2005 11:43 PM

"17. Legislating tons of laws which says "Don't do this, or don't 'wiretap' that or 'no jueteng there' with penalties of death a million times" do not mean anything unless the Law on Grand Jury and Trial Jury Systems is also enacted that will enable the common ordinary people or private citizens to exercise their independent sovereign deciding voice in their halls of justice to enforce such legislation." . . Paragraph 17, re: "Justice Reform is the Solution" . . http://anticorruption.homestead.com/Justice.html

Posted by: Marlowe Camello at July 6, 2005 11:36 AM

Post a comment









Remember personal info?